Website Template or Web Designer? How Therapists Should Choose
So many therapists start private practice because they want more freedom.
More flexibility.
More time for their families.
More say over how their days actually go.
And then comes the website. The fonts, the colors, the copy, the plugins, the "wait, where do I even put my location?" Suddenly the thing that was supposed to bring clients in is eating your Saturdays.
What if building your website didn't have to cost you your energy, or your nervous system?
What you'll learn about choosing between a website template and a web designer
In this episode of The Marketing Couch, I sit down with Meghan Tack, a Squarespace designer, SEO strategist, and the founder of Therapist Site Toolbox, a website template shop built specifically for therapists. Meghan is based in Ontario, Canada, and she started her journey as a therapist before pivoting into web design after noticing how few options out there captured the energy and professionalism of private practice owners.
Yes, we are both website designers. That is exactly why I wanted this conversation. We talk honestly about the question so many therapists are stuck on: should you buy a template, or hire a designer? We cover the pros and cons of each, which platform actually makes your life easier, what most DIY websites get wrong, and how to build a marketing strategy (hello, blogging and Pinterest) that does not depend on Instagram.
Episode topics
- 1:30 - How Meghan went from her counseling practicum to designing website templates for therapists
- 4:28 - Why WordPress felt too complicated, Showit offered too much flexibility, and Squarespace finally clicked
- 13:06 - What Meghan wishes more therapists knew before going the DIY route (design and strategy are not the same thing)
- 15:38 - What to check when your website is not converting or getting traffic
- 20:00 - What comes with a Therapist Site Toolbox template, how fast you can launch, and how semi-custom design works
- 23:37 - How blogging, SEO, and Pinterest grew Meghan's business without relying on Instagram
- 31:15 - The questions that help you decide between a template and a designer
- 37:15 - Website copy: when to write it yourself and when to get help
- 40:54 - The biggest mistakes Meghan sees on DIY therapist websites
- 42:59 - Why niching down feels scary (and why it is also empowering)
- 46:09 - What holistic success means to Meghan in this season of life and business
- 48:04 - Where to find Meghan and her free homepage strategy guide
How Meghan went from therapist-in-training to template designer
Meghan has always been a creative person (she will pick up a new hobby any day of the week). During her counseling practicum at a community mental health center, she knew she wanted to go into private practice after graduating. That meant she needed a website.
So in the evenings she started scrolling. And what she found for therapists just did not match how she wanted to show up online. Meanwhile, she kept stumbling onto beautiful, modern templates made for bloggers and other creatives and thinking, "Why doesn't this exist for us?"
The idea started small. Make her own site. Then maybe make templates for other therapists who were feeling just as stuck and confused. She was not looking for something cookie cutter or something that looked the same as what was popular ten years ago.
WordPress vs. Showit vs. Squarespace: choosing the platform that gives you peace of mind
This is where Meghan and I got a little nerdy, and I am not sorry.
Meghan tried WordPress first and found the learning curve so steep that she spent more time trying to understand the platform than actually creating something. Then she tried Showit, which she loves visually, but realized there is such a thing as too much flexibility. Most therapists just want a website that works, not a blank canvas where everything moves.
Squarespace was the one that clicked. It has structure, but you can still create something unique, and the tech felt learnable. Most importantly, it did not feel like one more giant job on a therapist's already long list.
I shared my own take too: I think of WordPress as the dinosaur platform. Plugins that need updating, security issues, hosting headaches. If another platform has SEO features built in on the back end, why spend your Saturdays reading WordPress tutorials? We also talked about how Showit needs a WordPress integration just to have a blog, which means paying for another hosting account.
The takeaway: every platform has pros and cons. Decide what your non-negotiables are, then choose the tool that gives you peace of mind.
Design and strategy are not the same thing
When I asked Meghan what she wishes more therapists knew before choosing the DIY route, her answer was clear: you can have the prettiest website in the world, but if it does not guide your visitor toward some kind of connection with you, it will not convert.
Before you touch a single font, get clear on three things: who you help, how you help them, and what you want a visitor to do next on every page of your site.
Visitors may not be able to explain why they are not having a good time on your website, but they can feel it. Your website is often the first impression, and people make split-second decisions about what feels trustworthy and aligned.
What to check when your website is not converting
If you built a site, you have copy, and no one is booking, what is going on? Meghan starts with an audit. Here is what she looks at:
- SEO basics, like missing meta titles and meta descriptions
- Whether there is a call to action in the first part of your homepage
- Whether it is obvious who you serve and where you serve them
That last one matters more than you would think. I have seen beautiful sites with great copy where nowhere in the header does it say where the therapist is located or who they work with. Put it in your header, or at least your footer, so people understand within the first 30 seconds.
Meghan's other tip: ask someone who is not a therapist to look at your site and tell you what they see and how they feel. Then really listen. When you are the one designing it, it is hard to see the forest for the trees.
What comes with a Therapist Site Toolbox template (and how long it takes to launch)
Meghan's templates come with preset pages, and you can use all of them or pick only the ones you need. Alongside the templates she offers resources to help therapists who have never built a website feel more confident:
- Video walkthroughs for editing the template and learning Squarespace
- Copy workbooks
- An SEO checklist
- Image resources, because sourcing high quality photos that fit your style is always a tough one
- A pre-launch checklist, so you know what can wait until after launch
If your copy and images are ready, you can have a template site live in a couple of days. For therapists who do not want to do the work themselves, Meghan also offers a semi-custom template service where she does the customization for you, including sourcing color palettes and creating a basic logo.
And if you are on the fence between a template and a custom design, you can start with the template. Meghan discounts the template cost if you decide to move into semi-custom or custom design later, so you are never paying twice.
Growing a business with blogging, SEO, and Pinterest (instead of Instagram)
Here is a part of the conversation I loved, because Meghan and I are on the exact same page. She has never been able to make Instagram feel sustainable, and she is proof that you do not have to.
Blogging and SEO made sense to her because it felt like planting seeds for long-term growth. Take a question a client could be asking, write a blog post that answers it, and let it live on your website working for you around the clock. Pinterest became a natural extension: write a post, create a couple of graphics in Canva, pin it, and now you have another little road leading back to your website.
Unlike a social post that disappears from the feed after a couple of days, these pieces keep showing up as long as the keywords are hitting. It takes time for Google to start trusting your site, but the effort compounds.
Meghan's advice: find a platform you actually enjoy and that does not drain your energy, because consistency is the biggest piece, and you will not stay consistent with something you dread.
Template or designer? The questions to ask yourself
Meghan boils the decision down to a few honest check-ins:
- Clarity. If you are really clear on your niche and messaging and you want to outsource, hiring a designer is a great fit. If you are still figuring out who you serve, a template can be empowering because you get to try things on and decide as you go.
- Capacity. Look at what your week actually looks like. If opening your laptop after a full day of sessions feels like the worst thing you could do with your evening, hire support.
- Decision fatigue. Some people love choosing fonts and moving sections around. For others, it is stressful and awful. Neither is wrong.
My own addition: if you go the DIY route, please do not do it entirely on your own. Start with a template that already has the structure therapists need. Your time is worth more than the rabbit hole.
Website copy: write it yourself or get help?
It depends on you. Some therapists are beautiful writers and want every word to be their own, and that is fantastic. If that is you, find a resource that gives you structure and strategy, especially around working keywords in naturally for both your reader and Google.
Others know who they serve but not what they want to say about it yet. In that case, working with a copywriter can feel freeing. Meghan describes her process as feeling like a podcast: she asks questions and writes furiously while the client shares honest answers.
Either way, strategy matters. Two thousand beautiful words on one page will not get read. A big part of copy strategy is knowing what to leave out.
The biggest mistakes Meghan sees on DIY therapist websites
The first is trying to be everything to everyone. Therapists are trained to hold space for so many experiences, so a homepage often turns into a laundry list: individuals, couples, teens, trauma, anxiety, depression. The intention is lovely, but the messaging gets diluted. A prospective client lands on the page and thinks, "That's great that you do 17 different things, but do you do my thing?"
The second is a lack of calls to action. Whether it is "schedule a free consultation" or "book now," you want that button in multiple places on every page, and definitely in the first third. Nobody wants to scroll all the way to the bottom to find out how to reach you.
Why niching down feels scary (and why it is worth it)
I see this with my own clients all the time: so many therapists are afraid to niche down because saying you serve everyone feels safe. But ask yourself who you actually enjoy working with. Even if only two of your current clients are postpartum moms, but those two light you up, you deserve a caseload full of them.
Meghan made a point I love: you can write your copy for a specific niche and someone outside that niche may still find it and connect. You can then decide if it is a good fit. Niching down does not mean turning everyone else away. It means being clear about where your messaging is pointed.
What holistic success means in this season of life and business
I closed by asking Meghan what holistic success means to her right now. Her answer: building a business that supports the life she wants to live, not one that consumes it.
As therapists, we talk about alignment and sustainability with our clients all day. Meghan realized the same applies to entrepreneurship, and that she does not want to grow at the expense of her health, her relationships, or her peace. She is focused on finding a way to create impact without burning out.
Connect with Meghan and grab her homepage strategy guide
You can find Meghan at therapistsitetoolbox.com, which is the hub for her templates, education, and resources. She is not very active on Instagram, so her website is the best place to reach her.
Listen to the full conversation on The Marketing Couch Podcast
Whether you hire a designer or start with a template, both paths are worth your time. The right choice is the one that fits your clarity, your capacity, and your energy.
You can listen to the full conversation with Meghan on The Marketing Couch Podcast on your favorite listening platform.
* AI Disclosure: This content may contain sections generated with AI with the purpose of providing you with condensed helpful and relevant content, however all personal opinions are 100% human made as well as the blog post structure, outline and key takeaways.
* Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on www.nataliamaganda.com may contain affiliate links meaning that I will get a commission for recommending products at no extra cost to you.

hello! i'm natalia maganda
The website manager for therapists and private practices that you didn't know existed.
We build and manage the 20+ page website that ranks in your city, reflects the depth of your work and books cash-pay clients with ease.
A done for you website management system that lets your practice grow without costing you your energy, your weekends, or your nervous system.






